How to Choose a Hiking Trail: 8 Things to Consider

Two hikers overlooking a mountain lake and jagged peaks along the Maple Pass Loop in North Cascades National Park
Disclaimer: Explore the Map contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and other affiliate programs. If you make a purchase using one of these affiliate links, I may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. Read my disclaimer for more information.

Hiking is easy enough, right? One foot after the other. It’s just like walking. Ha! Only sort of.

I’ve been hiking since I was a kid, and I’ve still managed to get myself into trouble by underestimating a trail. One of my more memorable mistakes was on Klahhane Ridge in Olympic National Park. We spotted a sign that said 3, assumed it meant kilometres (it was miles), and headed off without nearly enough water. In August. Great planning on our part!

I love a challenging hike, but there’s a difference between pushing yourself and getting in over your head. And it’s not always obvious which trails are going to be difficult. A short hike can be absolutely brutal, while a much longer one might actually be pretty manageable.

Knowing how to choose a hiking trail can save you from some pretty miserable experiences (I’ve had a few!). Here’s what I look at before deciding which trail to hike.

Hiker celebrating on a mountain trail surrounded by patches of snow and distant mountain views
Joss Mountain was one of the hardest hikes I’ve ever done, despite how short our route was!

1. Know Your Fitness & Experience Level

Before choosing a hiking trail, you need to be realistic about your fitness and experience level. It’s pretty easy to get excited about a hike with amazing views and convince yourself you can handle it. I’ve definitely done that more than once!

Being physically fit doesn’t necessarily mean you’re an experienced hiker, either. You might have no problem walking 15 km around town, but hiking uphill for hours on uneven terrain is a completely different experience. And if you’ve never hiked on loose rock or had to navigate a poorly marked trail, those things can make a hike much harder than you expected.

I’m a big believer in challenging yourself, but there’s a difference between a hike that’s going to push you and one you’re not prepared for. Jacob and I have chosen trails that were beyond our abilities before, and believe me, they’re not always fun experiences.

If you’re fairly new to hiking, start with trails you feel comfortable completing and gradually work your way up. You’ll build your endurance and get a better idea of what you can handle. And remember, there’s nothing wrong with turning around if a hike turns out to be more than you expected.

Hiker standing on a narrow alpine trail overlooking a mountain valley and winding river
The climb to Perley Rock is tough, but the glacier views are incredible!

2. Understand Trail Difficulty Ratings

Most hiking websites (me included) and apps rate trails as easy, moderate, or hard. Seems pretty straightforward, right? Well, not really.

The problem is that those ratings aren’t universal. What’s considered moderate in one park might be difficult somewhere else. And everyone’s idea of a hard hike is different, too. I’ve definitely finished hikes wondering who on earth decided they were moderate!

I still find difficulty ratings helpful, but I wouldn’t choose a trail based on that alone. Take a closer look at why it’s rated difficult. Is it a long hike? A steep climb? Does it involve scrambling over rocks? You might be perfectly comfortable with one of those and absolutely hate another.

Use the rating as a starting point, then dig into the actual trail details before deciding if it’s something you can handle.

Hiker celebrating on a rocky mountain ridge with jagged peaks and a turquoise alpine lake below
Maple Pass Loop has some of the most incredible mountain views I’ve ever hiked through

3. Look Beyond the Distance

Don’t assume a hike will be easy just because it’s short. I’ve made that mistake before, and Joss Mountain is probably my best example. We took a short route, around 4 km up if I’m remembering correctly, and it was the hardest hike I’ve ever done. Seriously.

The elevation gain can make a huge difference. A 5 km hike with 100 metres of elevation gain is going to feel very different from one that climbs 800 metres over the same distance. You’re covering the same ground, but you’re definitely not putting in the same amount of effort!

I always look at the elevation gain alongside the distance now. It gives you a much better idea of how much climbing you’re in for. And don’t forget about the downhill! Steep descents can be just as tiring, especially if your knees aren’t particularly fond of them.

I love using AllTrails for this because you can check the elevation profile and explore a 3D map of the trail. It’s so much easier to understand what you’re getting yourself into when you can actually see how steep the terrain is, rather than just looking at a bunch of numbers.

Hiker standing at a viewpoint overlooking the towering cliffs of Enderby Cliffs in British Columbia
I’ve been hiking Enderby Cliffs since I was a kid, and the views still get me every time!

4. Check the Terrain & Trail Conditions

Distance and elevation gain are important, but they don’t tell you everything about how difficult a hike will be. The actual trail can make a huge difference, too.

A well-maintained dirt trail is pretty different from one covered in loose rocks or tree roots. And then there are hikes where you’re scrambling up boulders, crossing streams, or walking along narrow ridges with steep drop-offs. Those can be a whole different challenge, especially if you’re not comfortable with heights!

I always try to get an idea of what the trail actually looks like before heading out. Photos and recent reviews on AllTrails are great for this. You can usually get a pretty good sense of whether it’s a straightforward hike or if there are sections that might be more difficult than you’d expect.

And pay attention to any warnings about exposure or scrambling. I’ve done hikes where the elevation gain wasn’t particularly intimidating, but the terrain made me a lot more nervous than the climb itself. There’s no shame in deciding a trail isn’t for you, even if other hikers say it’s easy.

Backpacker hiking through a dry, fire-scarred forest on a sunny day
Backpacking through the fire-scarred forests of Okanagan Mountain Provincial Park.

5. Consider the Weather & Season

A trail that’s perfectly manageable in the summer can be a completely different story when there’s snow or ice. And depending on where you’re hiking, winter conditions can stick around well into the summer.

I’ve definitely run into snow on mountain trails when everything down in the valley was already warm and sunny. It’s easy to forget how different conditions can be once you gain a bit of elevation!

Rain can make rocky trails slippery, and hot weather can turn an already difficult climb into a miserable experience. It’s also worth remembering that mountain weather can change quickly. Just because it’s sunny when you leave the trailhead doesn’t mean it’ll stay that way.

Before heading out, I always check the forecast for the actual area I’m hiking, not just the nearest town. I also look at recent trail reports to see if there’s still snow, muddy sections, or anything else that might make the hike more difficult.

And if the conditions look questionable, sometimes it’s better to save the hike for another day. I’m usually a little sad about it, especially if I’ve been looking forward to the trail, but I’d rather come back when I can actually enjoy it!

Stone mountain lookout shelter overlooking distant mountain ranges under a blue sky
The old fire lookout on Joss Mountain has some pretty spectacular views!

6. Check Recent Trail Reports

I almost always check recent trail reports before heading out on a hike, even if it’s somewhere I’ve been before. Trails can change a lot between visits, and I’d rather know about a washed-out bridge or a trail closure before I’ve driven two hours to get there!

AllTrails is usually my first stop. I love reading through the reviews to see what other hikers have experienced recently. People are pretty good about mentioning snow, muddy sections, or anything else that might make the hike more difficult than usual.

Just pay attention to when those reviews were posted. Someone saying a trail was snow-free in August doesn’t necessarily help if you’re planning to hike it in June. I’ll often scroll back a year to see what conditions were like around the same time I’m planning to go. It’s especially helpful for figuring out when the snow might melt, although conditions can be completely different from one year to the next.

I also check official park websites for closures and advisories, especially in national and provincial parks. AllTrails is fantastic for firsthand updates, but official sources are generally the best place to confirm whether a trail is actually open.

It’s a pretty quick bit of research that can save you a lot of frustration later!

Hiker standing on a rocky alpine trail overlooking a turquoise lake and rugged mountain peaks
Another reason I love Maple Pass Loop: those gorgeous turquoise lakes!

7. Give Yourself Enough Time

I almost always take longer to finish a hike than the estimated time. Sometimes a lot longer! I’m not particularly fast on the uphill sections, but I also don’t like rushing through hikes. I want to stop for photos and actually spend some time enjoying the views!

That’s why I always give myself plenty of extra time when choosing a trail. If AllTrails says a hike takes four hours, there’s a pretty good chance I’ll be out there longer.

One thing I really like about AllTrails is that you can look at individual hikers’ recordings, not just the average estimated time. You can see how long people actually took to complete the trail, which is helpful for getting a better idea of how much time to set aside. Just remember that some people practically run up mountains, so their hiking times might not be particularly realistic for you!

You also need to think about daylight, especially in the fall when the sun starts setting earlier. I don’t mind spending all day on a trail, but I definitely don’t want to be stumbling down a mountain in the dark because I underestimated how long it would take.

And if you’re taking longer than expected, don’t be afraid to turn around before reaching the end. It’s disappointing, especially when you’ve already put in a lot of effort, but the trail will still be there another day.

Two backpackers standing beside an alpine lake surrounded by mountains and evergreen trees
Sheila Lake is a beautiful stop on the Trophy Mountain trails in Wells Gray Provincial Park

8. Choose a Trail You’ll Actually Enjoy

Just because you can hike a trail doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll enjoy it. Everyone has different preferences, and there’s no point choosing a hike you’re going to hate the entire time!

Personally, I’m all about the views and alpine lakes. I love hiking up mountains and reaching a viewpoint where everything around me is so massive that I feel absolutely tiny. It’s one of my favourite feelings! And if there’s a lake I can jump into after a long climb, even better. I love swimming in mountain lakes, even when the water is freezing.

But not every hike needs to be a big mountain adventure. Sometimes I just want an easy walk through the forest, especially if I’m already tired or don’t have much time. And some of those shorter trails have been just as memorable as the difficult ones.

When I’m choosing a hike, I always look through photos to see what I’ll actually get to experience along the way. I also like knowing whether there are views throughout the trail or if I’ll be hiking through forest for hours before reaching a viewpoint.

At the end of the day, choose hikes that you’re excited about. It doesn’t matter whether they’re easy or difficult, as long as you’re getting out there and enjoying yourself!

Two backpackers smiling for a selfie while hiking through an alpine meadow
Our backpacking trip to Sheila Lake! I love getting out into the alpine with Jacob.

Final Thoughts on Choosing a Hiking Trail

Choosing the right hiking trail gets easier with experience, but even after years of hiking, I still occasionally underestimate how difficult a trail will be!

The biggest thing I’ve learned is to look beyond the distance and difficulty rating. A little research beforehand can make a huge difference, especially if you’re heading somewhere you’ve never hiked before.

And don’t be afraid to challenge yourself! Some of my favourite hikes have also been some of the hardest. I love that feeling of finally reaching the top after a tough climb, especially when the views are incredible.

Just make sure you know what you’re getting yourself into before heading out. And don’t forget to pack the 10 hiking essentials, even if you’re only planning a short hike. You can still have an adventure without accidentally making it quite so adventurous!